The Ultimate Content Audit How-To: A Step-by-Step Guide

Content is the backbone of your digital presence, but over time, even the best content can lose its impact. And let’s face it—coming up with endless new topics can be daunting. In fact, 57% of B2B marketers struggle to create relevant content for their audiences. If you're finding this relatable and nodding your head, it might be time for a content audit!

While a visually appealing website can attract visitors, it's the quality and relevance of your content that truly engages and converts them. However, over time, content can become outdated and simply not perform as well as it once could. A content audit, more than just a spring cleaning for your website, can help you uncover hidden opportunities, identify gaps, and refine your content to perfection.

This step-by-step guide will walk you through the entire process, from setting clear goals to measuring your results. It will also discuss the benefits of conducting a content audit, some inherent challenges, and best practices for successfully completing one to make the most of your content marketing efforts.

Main Takeaways From This Article:

• A comprehensive content audit process involves defining clear goals, creating an inventory, analyzing performance, and evaluating SEO elements of web pages.
• Tools like LinkScout simplify internal link management, ensuring all internal links are effectively optimized to boost site efficiency.
• Understanding the right timing for audits, like before a website redesign or when traffic declines, helps maintain content relevance and website health.
• Regular audits paired with documented learnings and automation tools facilitate iterative improvements and provide sustained value.

What Is a Content Audit?

A content audit is a systematic process of reviewing all content on your website to assess its performance, relevance, and effectiveness in achieving your website's goals. This involves analyzing various factors, including traffic, engagement, conversion rates, search engine optimization (SEO), and the content's alignment with your business objectives. 

Key Benefits of Content Audits

Content audits can provide significant value for your website and your business. Here are the key benefits to consider:

Improve SEO Performance and Rankings

Content audits unearth opportunities to optimize your content for relevant keywords, improve on-page SEO elements, and identify internal linking structures. This can lead to increased organic traffic and improved search engine rankings.

Identify Content Gaps and Opportunities

A comprehensive content audit reveals areas where your content might be lacking. It highlights gaps in your content strategy, uncovering topics you're not currently addressing but your audience might be searching for. This allows you to develop content that expands your reach and attracts new visitors.

Enhance User Experience and Engagement

Users expect high-quality, informative, and engaging content. Conducting a content audit helps ensure your content is well-structured, easy to navigate, and provides value to your audience. This improves user experience and encourages engagement.

Align Content With Business Goals

Audits allow you to assess if your content effectively supports your overall business goals, whether it be generating leads, driving sales, or promoting brand awareness. By focusing on high-performing content and creating content that drives traffic and supports conversions, you can maximize the return on your content investment.

Best Times to Run a Website Content Audit

Knowing when to perform an SEO content audit is just as important as knowing how to conduct one. Here are some key situations that warrant a fresh look at your content:

Before a Website Redesign

Before launching a website redesign, it's vital to understand what content is working well and what needs improvement. This audit will help ensure your new website design seamlessly integrates your content and maximizes its effectiveness.

When Organic Search Traffic Drops

If you are experiencing a decline in organic traffic, a content audit can help you pinpoint the underlying issues. The audit can reveal outdated content that needs to be refreshed, missing keywords, or a lack of high-quality content that is attracting visitors.

When Expanding Content or Adding New Topics

A content audit can be a valuable tool when you plan to expand your content library or explore new topic areas to offer your audience more valuable information. It can highlight potential content gaps and opportunities to create strategic content that your audience will value.

If Conversion Rates Are Low or Declining

Low conversions often stem from content that misses the mark, lacks a clear direction, or doesn't use a clear call to action. A content audit can help you identify these issues and optimize your content to boost conversions and achieve better results.

As Part of Routine Site Maintenance

Like any valuable asset, your website content benefits from regular upkeep. A content audit performed as part of your routine maintenance ensures your content remains fresh and relevant and continues to drive desired results.

The Content Audit Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

Now, let's explore how a content audit is performed, focusing on key actions and content audit tools to make the process easy and effective.

1. Define Goals for the Content Audit

Before you embark on your content audit, it's crucial to take a step back and define your goals. This will help you stay focused and ensure that your audit is successful.

Clarify Objectives

Are you aiming to improve SEO performance? Does user engagement need a boost? Or does the existing content not align with your new business objectives? Having specific objectives guides your interpretation of the audit findings. 

Identify Primary Focus Areas

Based on your chosen goals, determine which areas of your content require the most attention. This could be specific content types (e.g., blog posts, product pages), topics, or areas of the website where you suspect performance issues. Prioritizing areas allows you to manage time and resources effectively.

2. Create a Content Inventory

This step involves making a comprehensive list of all content on your website. Here are some common content types to consider: 

• Blog Posts: Include titles, URLs, publication dates, and author information.
• Product Pages: Include product names, descriptions, and URLs.
• Landing Pages: Include the page title, URL, and the specific marketing campaign or offer each page promotes.
• FAQs: Include titles, URLs, and topics covered.
• Resource Pages: Include titles, URLs, and the type of resource (e.g., whitepapers, ebooks, webinars).
• About and Contact Pages: Include URLs and key information on these pages.
• Category and Tag Pages: Include URLs and the categories or tags they represent.

Collecting Metadata and Performance Metrics

Beyond listing content URLs, consider including essential information like:

• Publish Date: Evaluate the content’s freshness and determine if updates are needed.
• Content Type: Organize content by type for a more targeted analysis.
• Word Count: Review content length to ensure it aligns with best practices for your goals.
• Author: Track ownership to streamline updates or accountability.
• Keyword Density: Analyze keyword usage to optimize content for SEO without overstuffing.
• Meta Description: Check for accuracy and optimization to improve search visibility.
• Heading Tags (H1, H2, etc.): Ensure proper structure and hierarchy for better readability and SEO.
• Image Alt Text: Verify alt text is accurate and descriptive to boost accessibility and SEO.
• Backlinks: Identify external links pointing to the content to assess link-building efforts.
• Social Shares: Monitor popularity on social media to understand audience engagement.
• Time on Page: Use as an indicator of how engaging or valuable users find the content.
• Bounce Rate: Investigate high bounce rates to uncover potential usability or content relevance issues.

Tool Recommendation: Screaming Frog SEO Spider

This powerful SEO tool can automate the process of crawling your website and gathering valuable metadata and performance metrics. It can identify broken links, missing meta tags, and other technical SEO issues. By using Screaming Frog, you can efficiently create a comprehensive content inventory and gain valuable insights into your website's health.

3. Analyze Content Performance Metrics

Once you have a comprehensive inventory, the next step is to analyze the performance metrics of your content. This will help you identify high-performing content, low-performing content, and opportunities for improvement.

Traffic Analysis

Analyze the sources of traffic to your website. Identify which channels drive the most traffic, such as organic search, social media, or email marketing. This will enable you to gain insights into your audience's origins and effectively optimize your content for those specific channels.

Engagement Metrics

Evaluate how users interact with your content. Look at metrics such as time on the page, bounce rate, and scroll depth. This will help you identify high-performing content that keeps users engaged and underperforming content that needs improvement.

Conversion Metrics

Track how well your content converts users into leads or customers. Analyze metrics like conversion rate, lead generation, and sales revenue. This will enable you to assess the impact of your content on achieving your business objectives.

Tool Recommendation: Google Analytics

Google Analytics can help you track and analyze a wide range of website performance metrics. By using this tool, you can gain valuable insights into how users interact with your content, which pages are most popular and which have high bounce rates, and where you can improve.

4. Assess Content Quality and Relevance

Assessing these factors is crucial to ensure that your content resonates with your target audience and ranks well in search engine results. You can identify areas for improvement and optimize your content accordingly.

Relevance Check

To ensure the relevance of your content, check if it directly addresses your target audience's pain points and interests. 

• Does it provide value?
• Is it accurate and up-to-date?
• Does it align with your overall content strategy?

Quality Markers

High-quality content is well-written, informative, and engaging. Look for factors like clarity, conciseness, originality, and depth. Well-structured content with clear headings and subheadings improves readability and user experience.

Content Gaps

Analyzing your competitors' content and conducting keyword research will illuminate gaps in your content marketing strategy. This will also help you identify new topics to cover and opportunities to expand on existing content.

Tool recommendation: MarketMuse 

MarketMuse is an AI-powered content optimization tool that helps you assess the quality and relevance of your content. It analyzes your content and provides insights into topic depth, keyword optimization, and content gaps. By using this tool, you can ensure your content is well-structured, keyword-optimized, and engaging.

5. Review SEO Elements

Optimizing your content for search engines is crucial to increasing visibility and attracting organic traffic. By reviewing your SEO elements, you can improve aspects that aren't already optimized and enhance your website's ranking, driving more visitors.

Keyword Optimization

This involves identifying relevant keywords and strategically incorporating them into your content. If your content isn't using relevant keywords in titles, headings, and body copy, add them to improve your search engine rankings and attract more organic traffic.

On-Page SEO

This step involves optimizing elements in your website's HTML code. These elements include title tags, meta descriptions, header tags, and image alt text. Optimizing these elements directly translates into an improved website's click-through rate and search engine rankings.

URL Structure and Mobile Compatibility

A clean and user-friendly URL structure can improve user experience and SEO. Use short, descriptive URLs that include relevant keywords to help search engines understand your page's content. Ensuring your website is mobile-friendly can attract a significant portion of internet traffic.

Tool Recommendation: Ahrefs

Ahrefs is a comprehensive SEO tool that analyzes your website's backlink profile, keyword rankings, and on-page SEO. It offers insights into performance and identifies improvement opportunities, helping you optimize your site for search engines and increase organic traffic.

6. Evaluate Content for Optimization Actions

Once you've analyzed your content, it's time to make decisions about how to optimize it. This involves evaluating each piece of content and determining the best course of action.

Evaluation Criteria

To assess content for optimization, consider its relevance to current trends, accuracy, and user engagement. Examine whether it aligns with your business goals and fulfills user intent. Apply rating scales or specific evaluation criteria to measure effectiveness across different content types.

Decision-Making Process

When deciding the fate of your content, focus on its importance to your audience and business goals. Categorize each piece as "keep," "remove," or "revise/optimize" based on performance data and relevance. This systematic approach facilitates informed decision-making grounded in actual analytical insights.

Tool Recommendation: SurferSEO

SurferSEO is an AI-powered SEO tool that can help you optimize your content. It provides recommendations for improving keyword density, content structure, and readability. This tool ensures that your content is optimized for search engines and user experience.

7. Evaluate Internal and External Links

Internal and external links play a crucial role in SEO and user experience. By evaluating and optimizing your link profile, you can improve your site's authority and visibility.

Importance of Internal and External Linking

Internal links help search engines discover and index your website pages, while external links to authoritative websites can improve your website's credibility and relevance. Both types of links can help distribute link equity and improve your website's search engine rankings.

Optimize Internal Links for Navigation and SEO

Internal links are vital for guiding users through your site and signaling content relationships to search engines. Regularly evaluate internal links to ensure they are relevant and strategically placed to enhance navigation and boost page authority. Look for opportunities to create new internal links to high-value content and fix broken or outdated links.

Evaluate External Links for Quality and Relevance

Make sure that the external links on your website are high-quality and relevant. Avoid linking to low-quality or spammy websites, as this can negatively impact your website's SEO. Focus on linking to authoritative websites that can add value to your content.

Tool Recommendation: LinkScout

LinkScout is an AI-powered tool focused on internal link management. It helps you identify and implement internal link opportunities, refresh outdated links, and optimize your website's link structure. With LinkScout, you can enhance your internal link profile and boost your SEO performance.

Acting on Your Audit Findings

Once you've completed your content audit, it's time to take action and implement the necessary changes.

Content Optimization Techniques

Here are three main strategies to optimize your content based on your audit findings:

1. Update or Refresh Content: If you find outdated content, update it with the latest information. You can also refresh existing content by adding new insights, statistics, or examples to make it more engaging and valuable to your audience.
2. Consolidate or Remove Content: Merge similar content into a single, comprehensive piece to avoid duplicate content and improve website performance. Remove low-performing or outdated content that no longer serves a purpose.
3. Expand Thin Content: Content that is too short or lacks depth can negatively impact your website's SEO. To improve such content, add more information, examples, or case studies. You can also break up long-form content into smaller, more digestible pieces to improve readability.

Documentation of Changes

To ensure a smooth and organized process, it's essential to document all changes made to your content. Create a content audit spreadsheet with a change log that includes the following information:

• Date of Change: Track when the changes were made.
• Content URL: Identify the specific page or post that was modified.
• Type of Change: Specify the nature of the change (e.g., updated, deleted, added).
• Reason for the Change: Explain why the change was necessary.
• Person Responsible: Indicate who made the change.

A detailed change log for content audit data helps track the progress of your content optimization efforts and identify areas for further improvement.

Common Pain Points During a Content Audit

Conducting a comprehensive content audit has some inherent challenges:

Time-Consuming Process

Auditing a large website can be a time-consuming process, especially if done manually. It requires careful analysis of each piece of content, which can be tedious and overwhelming.

Organizing the Audit Data

As you gather information from various sources, it's important to organize the data in a clear and structured way. This can be challenging, especially when dealing with large datasets.

Decision Fatigue

Making decisions about which content to update, remove, or create can be mentally draining. Analyzing numerous pieces of content and prioritizing optimization efforts can lead to decision fatigue.

Best Practices for a Successful Content Audit

To ensure a successful content audit, implement these best practices:

Set Clear Objectives from the Start

Without clear objectives, the content audit process can become disorganized and inefficient. You may end up analyzing irrelevant content, wasting time and resources. Clear objectives guide the entire process, ensuring that the audit focuses on the most critical areas and delivers actionable insights.

Leverage Automation Tools

When conducting a content audit, it is important to leverage automation tools to streamline the process. Tools like Link Scout, Google Analytics, and Ahrefs can help you gather data, analyze performance metrics, and identify optimization opportunities.

Establish a Regular Audit Cycle

Regularly conducting content audits is crucial to ensure your website remains both high-quality and relevant. By sticking to a consistent audit schedule, you'll be able to pinpoint and rectify potential issues early on, preventing them from escalating into bigger problems.

Monitor Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

Track key performance indicators like organic traffic, bounce rate, and conversion rate to measure the impact of your content audit. This will enable you to find opportunities for further optimization and refine your content strategy accordingly.

Plan for Iterative Improvements

Content audits are an ongoing process, so it's important to continuously monitor your website's performance. By making regular adjustments and optimizations, you can ensure that your content remains relevant, engaging, and effective.

Simplify Your Content Audit With LinkScout’s AI-Driven Link Optimization

A content audit can be a powerful tool for identifying areas to improve your website's performance. However, the sheer volume of content and the need for in-depth analysis can make it a time-consuming process. LinkScout’s AI-powered internal linking tool simplifies your content audit by automating internal linking tasks and identifying new opportunities for optimization.

Our tool automatically suggests and implements internal links throughout your content, saving you valuable time and effort. It also enhances user navigation and boosts your website’s search engine ranking by optimizing internal link structures. While LinkScout does not specifically identify or repair broken links, its features ensure that your internal links remain fresh and relevant.

So, are you ready to streamline your content audit and unlock your website's full potential?

Get Started With a Free Trial